Medical over-, underuse should be confronted globally

11 January 2017 | Gesondheid
A five-part series of papers on medical underuse and overuse, commissioned by The Lancet, and led by the Lown Institute in Boston, calls for health policy makers and pro­viders to take urgent action and expand research to tackle underuse and overuse together, factors leading to widespread poor health care across the globe. The papers, titled The Right Care Series, are authored by 27 international experts and are available online and at a special all-day launch event held at King's College London on January 9.

The series explores the scope, causes, consequences of, and potential remedies for underuse and overuse of health care around the world. Underuse leaves patients vulnerable to avoidable disease and suffering; overuse causes avoidable harms from tests or treatments, while simultaneously wasting resources better spent on services needed for health. Both can occur in the same country, same organization, or health facility, and even afflict the same patient. Getting better value from health care is a challenge common to all nations, regardless of economic status or social system, the authors conclude.

“Greed, competing interests and poor information are universal drivers that can form an ecosystem of poor health care delivery,” said Vikas Saini, MD, president of Lown Institute and a lead author. “Citizens all over the world need to understand these forces if they are to defend and promote their financial security, safety, health and well-being.”

The authors conclude that overuse and underuse, the failure to deliver needed care, are epi­demic around the world. ­Examples cited in the series include rates of ­inappropriate total knee replacements, 26 percent in Spain and 34 percent in the U.S.; and rates of in­appropriate hysterectomies, 20 percent in Taiwan and 13 percent in Switzerland.

A common tragedy in both wealthy and poor countries is the use of expensive and sometimes ineffective technology while low-cost effective interventions are neglected. Thus the C-section rates are soaring in many countries around the world for low-risk births while the simple use of steroids to prevent premature births has lagged for 40 years since the first evidence was published. Research indicates that up to 6.6 million C-sections around the world are excessive.

“Patients and citizens need to understand what's at stake here if their health systems fail to address these twin problems,” said Shannon Brownlee, MSc, Lown Institute senior vice president, another lead author. “In the U.S., we are wasting billions of dollars that should be devoted to improving the nation's health.”

In a companion editorial, Don Berwick, MD, president emeritus of the Institute for Healthcare Improvement and former head of the U.S. Centers of Medicare & Medicaid Services, affirms that the papers lay out a framework for a major new area of work to achieve better care and more sustainable costs.

He also urges health ­ministries and legis­latures to take action. “This landmark series on overuse and underuse constitutes a call-to-arms to improve health care globally by better matching care to needs, and practice to science.”

Writing in a commentary accompanying the series, Richard Horton, editor-in-chief of The Lancet, and Sabine Kleinert, senior executive editor, stressed “Global health leaders need to recognize the opportunity to eliminate poor care and provide right care as the answer to truly and sustainably achieve healthy lives and wellbeing for all.”

Adam Elshaug, PhD, co-director of the Menzies Centre for Health Policy, The University of Sydney, and senior fellow at the Lown Institute, was another lead author, along with Paul ­Glasziou, FRACGP, professor of evi­dence-based medicine at Bond University. Co-­authors of the papers are from such institutions as the World Bank, Harvard, Stanford, Dartmouth and the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development.



Net span nouer om Otji-dok

2 ure gelede | Howe

Denver Kisting - Die ministerie van gesondheid en maatskaplike dienste ondersoek 'n klag van diefstal teen Otjiwarongo se omstrede dokter, dr. Yeukai Chiradza.Volgens die registrateur...

Listeriose is hier

2 ure gelede | Gesondheid

Henriette Lamprecht - Die ministerie van gesondheid en maatskaplike dienste het sy gesondheidsinpekteurs opdrag gegee om seker te maak alle kleinhandelaars in die land...


2 ure gelede | In beeld

Die tweejarige Kylie Pienaar spog met haar twee reuse-omajovas op die plaas Jagerhof in die Otjiwarongo-omgewing. Volgens haar ma, Leandri Pienaar, is dit die...

Weer vir 14 Maart 2018

2 ure gelede | Weer

BINNELAND: Gedeeltelik bewolk en warm tot baie warm met enkele buie oor die sentrale dele. In die Noorde sal geïsoleerde donderbuie voorkom. KUS: Gedeeltelik...

Antie Nora teer onthou

2 ure gelede | Mense

Denver Kisting - Toe die 77-jarige politieke vuurvreter me. Nora Schimming-Chase gisteroggend om 02:32 sterf, was sy deur haar hartsmense omring.Haar twee dogters, ­advokaat Esi...

'Jy kan moraliteit nie reguleer'

2 ure gelede | Gesondheid

Henriette Lamprecht - Meer as die helfte van die sowat 7 000 miskrame wat vanjaar in gesondheidsgeriewe dwarsoor die land behandel is, is self teweeg...

Unam stel Inceptus bekend

2 ure gelede | Onderwys

Augetto Graig - Die Universiteit van Namibië (Unam) het reeds aansoeke ontvang vir die pos van hoofbestuurder vir Inceptus Holding.Dié nuwe maatskappy is deur die...

Govt concerned about trade union members

2 ure gelede | Arbeid

President Hage Geingob said he would like the National Union of Namibian Workers (NUNW) to know that his administration is concerned about trade union members.In...

Roei vir renosters by Auas Valley

2 ure gelede | Plaaslik

Kom roei ten bate van renosters op 28 Maart by die Auas Valley-inkopiesentrum in Windhoek. Op dié Woensdagaand kan die publiek tot 20:00 by dié...